Bill 190 Myths — What Ontario Employers Keep Getting Wrong
Bill 190 has been in force for over six months now, and a body of folklore has grown up around it. Some of it comes from well-meaning summaries that compressed a nuance out of existence. Some of it comes from vendors — including, it has to be said, several washroom compliance software companies — repeating a number nobody checked.
The problem with compliance folklore is that it makes employers either complacent or panicked, and neither is useful. Here are the myths worth clearing up, with the actual position on each.
Myth 1: “The fine is $100,000”
This is the most widespread and the most demonstrably wrong. Search “Bill 190 fines” and you’ll find multiple washroom compliance vendors stating that Ontario employers face fines up to $100,000 for non-compliance.
There is no $100,000 fine in the OHSA. The figure does not correspond to any maximum in the Act.
The actual maximums on conviction under the OHSA are:
-
Corporations: up to $2,000,000 per offence
-
Directors and officers: up to $1,500,000, and/or up to 12 months imprisonment
-
All other individuals: up to $500,000, and/or up to 12 months imprisonment
The corporate maximum went from $1.5 million to $2 million in October 2023 under the Working for Workers Act, 2023 — which is where a lot of stale $1.5M references come from. Ontario now has the highest corporate OHS penalty in Canada.
So where did $100,000 come from? The most likely source is a garbled reference to Administrative Monetary Penalties. Ontario Regulation 365/25 sets a penalty for one specific procurement-related contravention at the lesser of $100,000 or 10% of the contract value. It has nothing to do with washrooms. Someone read it, connected it to the wrong regulation, and it propagated.
Why this matters: if you’re citing $100,000 in a business case for compliance spend, you’re understating corporate exposure by a factor of twenty — and anyone who checks will discount everything else you said.
Myth 2: “An inspector can hit you with an AMP for a missing log”
Related to Myth 1, and equally wrong.
Administrative Monetary Penalties came into force on January 1, 2026 under Part IX.1 of the OHSA, introduced by the Working for Workers Seven Act, 2025 and implemented through O. Reg. 365/25. They let an inspector impose a financial penalty directly, without a prosecution. If you pay an AMP, you can’t be charged with an offence for the same contravention.
That’s all true. Here’s what gets left out: the regulation as currently drafted prescribes exactly one contravention for which an AMP may be issued — failing to treat accredited health and safety management systems as equivalent during a public sector procurement process, under section 3 of O. Reg. 364/25.
That’s it. One. An inspector cannot currently issue you an AMP for a washroom record violation, because washroom records aren’t on the list.
Legal commentators broadly expect this to change — section 69.1 of the OHSA is drafted far more broadly than the regulation currently uses, and Mathews Dinsdale among others have noted the regulation will likely be amended because the current version doesn’t create the complete AMP system the Act contemplates.
Why this matters: not as a reason to relax. The enforcement machinery is built and the list is short but expandable. If record-keeping is added, exposure changes overnight with no warning period. But you should know what an inspector can and can’t do today.
Myth 3: “The regulation requires you to keep records for 12 months”
You’ll see this stated as a hard requirement. It isn’t one.
O. Reg. 480/24 requires that the record include the date and time of the two most recent cleanings. That’s the entire content requirement. There is no prescribed retention period anywhere in the regulation for general employers.
Twelve months is sound guidance — it aligns with common practice for OHSA-adjacent documentation and gives you something to show an inspector who wants to assess whether your program is genuine. We recommend it. But recommending it and claiming the law mandates it are different things, and vendors who blur that line are eroding their own credibility.
The one place a retention period is prescribed: construction. Under O. Reg. 482/24, a constructor’s record must cover services for the past six months or the duration of the project, whichever is shorter. That’s a real, legislated window.
Myth 4: “Small businesses are exempt”
No. O. Reg. 480/24 contains no small-employer exemption. If you employ workers under the OHSA and you provide washroom facilities for them, the obligation applies.
The confusion likely comes from other parts of the OHSA that do have headcount thresholds — Joint Health and Safety Committees are required at 20 or more workers, for instance. Those thresholds don’t carry across.
A two-person shop with one staff washroom has the same record-keeping obligation as a manufacturing plant with forty.
Myth 5: “Our cleaning contractor handles compliance”
Your cleaning contractor handles cleaning. The compliance obligation sits with you as the employer providing the facility to workers.
You can absolutely have your contractor perform the logging as part of their service — most do, and it’s the sensible arrangement. But if the logs aren’t there when an inspector asks, “our contractor was supposed to do it” is not a defence. It’s an explanation for why you failed.
Practically: put the requirement in the service agreement in writing, and monitor it yourself. Don’t wait for the contractor to tell you there’s a gap.
Myth 6: “A sign saying ‘cleaned daily’ counts”
It doesn’t. The regulation requires the date and time of the two most recent cleanings. Not a policy statement. Not a frequency claim. Specific, dated, timed entries for two specific cleaning events.
A sign that says “This washroom is cleaned daily” is marketing copy. It’s not a record.
Similarly: a record showing only dates and no times is incomplete. This is one of the most common real-world gaps, because people know they need to log cleanings and don’t realise the time is a separate mandatory field.
Myth 7: “One log for the building is fine”
The regulation requires the record to be posted in or near the washroom facility to which the record pertains, where it’s likely to come to the attention of workers.
That phrasing does the work. A consolidated log at reception covering every washroom in the building doesn’t satisfy it for a worker standing in a third-floor washroom. Each facility needs its own accessible record.
Myth 8: “Electronic records are risky / not really allowed”
Electronic records are expressly permitted. O. Reg. 480/24 offers two routes: post the record conspicuously in or near the washroom, or post it electronically where workers can access it, with workers given direction on where and how to access it.
Both are compliant. The electronic route has one extra condition — the direction on access — which is why a QR code with a “scan for cleaning record” label works so well: the code is the access method and the label is the direction, both mounted at the point of use.
Myth 9: “We’ll get a warning first”
There’s no statutory grace period. The regulation came into force January 1, 2026 and it’s enforceable now.
Whether you get a verbal caution or a written order on a first minor gap is inspector discretion, not entitlement. And an inspector doesn’t need a complaint to visit — Ontario runs annual sector inspection campaigns, with construction, health care, industrial, mining and retail workplaces among the current focus areas.
The Pattern Worth Noticing
Most of these myths share a shape: someone took a real fact from an adjacent regulation and attached it to this one. The $100,000 is real — for procurement. The AMP regime is real — for one contravention. The six-month retention is real — for construction. The 20-worker threshold is real — for JHSCs.
Compliance folklore is rarely invented. It’s usually a true thing in the wrong place. Which is a decent reason to check the primary source — O. Reg. 480/24 is a short read on Ontario’s e-Laws site, and the whole operative section is two subsections long.